For CFOs · One-page sheet
An AI business case is on your desk. What do you check?
To review an AI business case as a CFO, check eight things, in this order. A business case is written by the person asking for the money. This sheet is for the person who has to say yes or no.
I keep seeing cases that are strong on what the AI will do and thin on what it costs to keep running. The sheet starts there. You can go through it in the meeting, with the requester in the room.
The checklist
One row per question. Tick the row when the answer matches the middle column. Two or more rows in the right-hand column, and the case goes back for another round before it gets money.
| # | Ask | A good answer | Stop and look closer if |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | What does this work cost today? | Hours and euros, measured before anything is built. | There is no before number, only a forecast. |
| 2 | What does it cost to run for three years? | Licences, usage bills, and the people who keep it working. | Only the build or the first-year licence is priced. |
| 3 | What exactly does it replace, add or protect? | One thing, named, with a euro figure next to it. | The answer is productivity in general. |
| 4 | Whose budget changes if it works? | A named person who agrees their budget or target moves. | The benefit lands everywhere and in nobody's numbers. |
| 5 | What stops to make room for it? | A tool, a report or a task that ends when this starts. | Nothing stops. It is added on top. |
| 6 | Which decision will be made differently? | One decision, who makes it, and how often. | Nobody can name a decision. |
| 7 | Who keeps it working after launch? | A named owner with time set aside for it. | The team that builds it moves on at launch. |
| 8 | When do we review it, and what result ends it? | A date and a number, agreed now. | Review is left open, or the pilot has no end date. |
How to read the answers
Rows 1 and 2 are the cost
If either is missing, the return in the case cannot be checked later. Ask for the before number first.
Rows 3 to 6 are the return
A return needs an owner and something that stops. A case can be honest and still fail here, because the saving was never assigned to anyone.
Rows 7 and 8 are the exit
Agreeing the stop rule before approval is easier than after. Nobody is attached to the work yet.
The workshop on what AI spend returns and what to stop paying for.